Potential benefit of consolidation
Extra in your pot at retirement by switching to fees
from
over years
Total Fees Saved
Over the full term
Fee Comparison
Starting Pot Value
Monthly Contributions
Growth Rate (before fees)
Total Fees (Current Scheme)
Total Fees (New Scheme)
Consolidation Bonus
Chart
Year-by-Year
Current Fees ( %)
New Fees ( %)
Projected values assuming constant growth and fees. Actual returns will vary.
Year
Current Fees
New Fees
Difference
Estimated Cash Equivalent Transfer Value
/year pension
× transfer multiple
Estimated CETV
Lump sum today
Critical Yield
Return needed to match DB
Risk Level
Based on critical yield
Critical Yield Assessment
0%
3.5%
5%
10%+
Lower Risk
Moderate Risk
Higher Risk
To match your guaranteed DB income of ,
you would need your transferred pot to achieve
annual returns after charges, every year, for the rest of your life.
Risk bands are illustrative only and are not FCA-mandated thresholds. Individual circumstances vary.
Keep vs Transfer Comparison
Feature
Keep DB Pension
Transfer Out
Income
Guaranteed for life
Depends on investment returns
Flexibility
Fixed payment schedule
Full control over drawdown
Inflation
Usually index-linked
Depends on investment strategy
Death Benefits
Reduced spouse pension
Full pot to beneficiaries
Investment Risk
None — employer bears risk
You bear all risk
Tax-Free Cash
25% of CETV (via commutation)
25% of full transfer value
By law, you must seek independent financial advice before transferring a defined benefit pension with a transfer value over £30,000. This is a legal requirement, not a suggestion.
Your pension includes a Guaranteed Annuity Rate (GAR). This is a valuable benefit that provides a higher guaranteed income than you could buy on the open market. Transferring out means you lose this guarantee permanently. Think very carefully before proceeding.
If you're not sure whether your pension has a Guaranteed Annuity Rate, contact your scheme administrator and ask. GARs can significantly increase the value of your pension and are easily overlooked.
Transfer values are sensitive to interest rates and gilt yields. When interest rates rise, transfer values typically fall. The figure shown is an estimate — your scheme administrator will provide the actual CETV, which is only guaranteed for a limited period (usually 3 months).
This comparison assumes constant growth rates and charges over the full term. In practice, investment returns vary year to year. Even small fee differences compound significantly over long periods — a 0.5% fee reduction on a £100,000 pot over 20 years could be worth over £15,000.
How this is calculated
Defined Contribution — Fee Consolidation: Projects your pension pot forward under two fee scenarios using compound growth. Each year, the pot grows by the growth rate minus the annual fee, plus any ongoing contributions. The "consolidation bonus" is the difference between the two projected outcomes.
Defined Benefit — CETV Estimate: The Cash Equivalent Transfer Value is estimated by multiplying your annual pension benefit by a transfer multiple. This multiple reflects current market conditions, gilt yields, and your age.
Critical Yield: The annual investment return your transferred pot would need to achieve, after charges, to replicate the guaranteed income from the DB scheme. This is calculated by finding the rate at which the CETV, growing over the years to retirement, could sustain the annual pension benefit for an assumed 28-year retirement (planning for longevity).
Risk Assessment: A critical yield below 3.5% is generally considered achievable with a balanced portfolio. Between 3.5% and 5% carries moderate risk. Above 5% means you would need consistently strong investment returns to match the DB guarantee — historically difficult to sustain.
These are estimates only. Always seek independent financial advice before making any pension transfer decisions.
Recalculate
Year
Current Fees
New Fees
Difference
Feature
Keep DB Pension
Transfer Out
Income
Guaranteed for life
Depends on returns
Flexibility
Fixed schedule
Full control
Investment Risk
None
You bear all risk
Death Benefits
Reduced spouse pension
Full pot to beneficiaries
Legal requirement: You must seek independent financial advice before transferring a DB pension over £30,000.
Estimates only. Seek independent financial advice.
www.moneyhelpdesk.com